Hank's British punk rock neighbour Russ Binder (Matt Smith) tells him he needs to return home to London quickly to see his ailing father, leaving Hank to care for his cat, Bud. Knocking on Russ's apartment door, two Russian mobsters, Aleksei (Yuri Kolokolnikov) and Pavel (Nikita Kukushkin), viciously beat Hank when he claims not to know of Russ's whereabouts, resulting in Hank losing a kidney, as well as his ability to drink alcohol (as Yvonne tells him that the kidney's process toxins, and alcohol is a toxin, and without a kidney it could result in his death). After the Russians break into Russ's apartment, narcotics detective Elise Roman (Riegina King) questions Hank and reveals Russ is a drug dealer connected to notorious Hasidic brothers Lipa (Liev Schreiber) and Shmully (Vincent D'Onofrio) Drucker.
Finding a key hidden in a fake cat turd in Bud's litter box, Hank notifies Roman when the Druckers search Russ's apartment. After spending a drunken night at Paul's Bar, Hank strips down to his jocks and leaves his clothes outside his building after he vomits over himself. The next morning he is interrogated by the Russians and their Puerto Rican associate Colorado (Benito Martinez Ocasio), Hank cannot remember what happened to the key, but the mobsters are interrupted by his neighbour Duane (George Abud) who threatens to call the Police. Hank leaves the injured Bud with Yvonne, and remembers taking the key to the bar and giving it to the bars owner Paul (Griffin Dunne), for safe keeping. Chased by the Druckers, he informs Colorado, who mentions Yvonne. Realising she is in danger, he races back to her apartment, only to find she has been killed, shot through the head at point blank range.
Hank recovers the key from the homeless Jason (Will Brill), left in the trouser pocket he abandoned the night before. Russ returns home, but is hit in the head with a baseball bat when Hank mistakes him for an intruder. Russ explains that after selling drugs for the Druckers in Colorado's nightclubs, he was forced to involve Roman, who owes money to the Russians' boss. The key unlocks a storage unit with just over US$4M in cash that he was meant to split between the various parties on the day he left for London. Fearing for his life, Russ prepares to take the money and flee the country, leaving Hank as the fall guy, but Hank knocks him unconscious.
Hank is woken early the next morning on the beach by a call from Roman, who has framed him for the various murders and threatens his mother by telling Hank her address, demanding he bring the key to the Russians' supper club. Calling to warn his mother, Hank surrenders himself to the Druckers. They agree to kill Roman in exchange for Hank leading them to the money, first bringing him to their mother's (Carol Kane) Shabbos (day of rest on the seventh day of the week) dinner. The Druckers then zip-tie Hanks hands to the car's steering wheel while the heavily-armed brothers storm the club, shooting and bombing the place up.
Seeing Roman fleeing from the unfolding scene at the club, Hank burns his restraints with the cars cigarette lighter and gives chase with a baseball bat that he purloined from a bunch of kids having a hit in the street. He subdues a vengeful Pavel with a swift one-two punch to the head and manages to injure Roman by impaling her foot with the broken baseball bat handle, at which point the Druckers arrive and shoot her dead. Hank reveals he hid the key in the bandage on Bud's leg, and the sympathetic brothers decide to let him live with a US$100K share of the money.
They force him to drive for the first time since his fateful crash that cost Dale his life, when Hank notices that Lipa has Yvonne's unique pistol shaped cigarette lighter. Realising the implication, the brothers admit they killed Yvonne to send a message to Hank for evading them. Aware that he's the only one wearing a seat belt, Hank increases speed and purposefully crashes the car squarely into a steel pillar, mirroring the crash of his earlier life, this time killing the two brothers outright.
Some time later, Hank poses as Russ, using his British passport to escape the country with Bud and half of the money. Calling his mother to let her know he is safe, Hank arrives in Tulum to begin a new life as he dreamed of doing, having mailed his mother (Laura Dern in an uncredited cameo) the other half of the money.
I really enjoyed 'Caught Stealing' and say what you will about Darren Aronofsky's back catalogue of movies, this film represents a marked departure from his previous works as he delivers us a grounded story set in late 1990's crime fuelled NYC, backed up by an ensemble eclectic cast led most notably by a stellar turn from Austin Butler, and a tightly wrought plot that is not short on attention grabbing violence and mayhem, but also delivers enough emotional heft and moments of humour to counter the numerous on-screen deaths and beatings. As far as crime thrillers go, you'ld be hard pressed to find a better film released so far this year.
'Caught Stealing' merits four claps of the Odeon Online clapperboard from a possible five claps.
-Steve, at Odeon Online-